four reasons why the government’s model for outsourcing is broken

For over a decade, the Put up Workplace and its provider, Fujitsu, insisted that the Horizon system utilized in its branches was utterly “strong”. When discrepancies appeared in a whole lot of department accounts throughout the nation, the Put up Workplace refused to imagine the system was at fault and didn’t problem the data it bought from Fujitsu. As a substitute, it blamed the shortfalls on sub-postmasters, made them pay the losses, and prosecuted over 700 of them.

The multimillion-pound contract between the Put up Workplace and Fujitsu is on the coronary heart of the scandal. The best way the contract labored meant that Fujitsu was incentivised to repair bugs rapidly fairly than nicely. The Put up Workplace didn’t have the experience it wanted to grasp what was going improper. The Put up Workplace’s dependence on Fujitsu additionally meant that it protected its relationship with them on the expense of sub-postmasters and the general public.

The issues with the Horizon contract underpin probably the most widespread miscarriages of justice in UK historical past. However they’re additionally replicated throughout 1000’s of different authorities contracts, together with for a lot of important companies, from hip replacements on the NHS to high school PE classes.

These issues are in truth produced by elementary options of the UK’s outsourcing mannequin.

1. The programs are too complicated to grasp

The Horizon system was extremely complicated. It needed to course of all types of transactions, from promoting travellers cheques to managing lease funds, throughout tens of 1000’s of disparate branches, utilizing an advanced net of communications programs.

The issue is, by outsourcing such a posh service, the Put up Workplace ended up with out the experience to grasp the way it labored and what Fujitsu was (or wasn’t) doing. The contract additionally restricted the quantity of data they may get from the system. This all meant that the Put up Workplace lacked the understanding and details about Horizon it might have wanted to problem the story it was getting from Fujitsu.

In its most up-to-date assertion on the inquiry into what occurred on the Put up Workplace, Fujitsu stated “the inquiry has bolstered the devastating influence on postmasters’ lives and that of their households, and Fujitsu has apologised for its function of their struggling … Fujitsu is absolutely dedicated to supporting the inquiry so as to perceive what occurred and to be taught from it.”

2. Contracts generate perverse incentives

If a service is complicated, like Horizon was, it’s inconceivable to specify all the things in a written contract. Any purchaser has to overlook issues out. However then how do they get a provider to do all the things they want and never simply the issues within the contract?

One of many causes Horizon had main issues was that it was inconceivable to say upfront how every bug within the system ought to be fastened. As a substitute, the contract simply stipulated how rapidly Fujitsu wanted to resolve issues. Bugs both weren’t fastened correctly or the fixes launched totally different bugs into the system. This sort of “service degree settlement” remains to be normal in lots of authorities contracts.

3. The client is locked in

Advanced companies additionally require a provider to put money into issues like software program, tools and coaching which are particular to that service. There’s an concept in economics that if a provider must make these “specialised investments”, it’s very troublesome to eliminate that provider. They’ve an enormous benefit over their opponents, as a result of anybody else would want to make these investments over again.

Learn extra:
Put up Workplace scandal: why 1000’s of victims are but to see justice

That is what occurred with the Horizon contract. As soon as Fujitsu had constructed the system, it couldn’t get replaced by one other provider, even when issues went improper. Within the authentic procurement, it scored backside on eight of the ten high quality standards, however received the contract as a result of it stated it might pay for the up-front improvement prices. The contract has since modified, however Fujitsu carried on and has simply had its contract renewed as much as 2025.

Getting locked into complicated contracts is kind of widespread for presidency. In 2014 HMRC introduced that it might finish its £8 billion contract with Capgemini for the UK’s tax assortment system. It needed to assign a finances of £700 million simply to pay for the price of transferring the contract to new suppliers. Now, ten years on, Capgemini remains to be the provider. Apparently unable to seek out another, HMRC ended up extending the contract to not less than 2025.

4. Suppliers are prioritised over employees and the general public

As a result of it couldn’t exchange them, the Put up Workplace trusted Fujitsu. This was compounded by the truth that Horizon was additionally important to the Put up Workplace’s enterprise. Horizon was chargeable for processing all department transactions and retaining monitor of all cash coming in and going out.

Dropping Fujitsu would trigger large value and disruption to a vital system. The Put up Workplace trusted retaining Fujitsu onside throughout contract negotiations and ensuring they have been financially wholesome. Predictably, they protected that relationship over sub-postmasters, who have been individually expendable. This additionally got here on the public’s expense, who bought a poor service and have needed to foot the invoice for the Put up Workplace’s mistake.

Learn extra:
Put up Workplace scandal: what the dearth of motion tells you about Britain’s polarised politics

Important public companies throughout the UK depend on a couple of “strategic suppliers”. Authorities our bodies are depending on defending their relationships with these suppliers and are invested of their monetary stability. The collapse of Carillion in 2018, at a time when it was contracted to construct NHS hospitals, introduced house simply how unhealthy issues may very well be if a significant provider went underneath.

How far the federal government would go to guard different strategic relationships stays to be seen. However so long as UK authorities our bodies outsource complicated, important companies, it’s unlikely that the Horizon fiasco would be the final public scandal with a authorities contract at its coronary heart.